In the realm of cinema, there exists a captivating niche: films set in the unique and somewhat peculiar world of early '70s British academia. This visual paradox, as I like to call it, presents a fascinating contrast between the youthful aspirations of students and the nicotine-stained legacy of their parents' generation. It's a world where beer is served in heavy mugs, and 'snugs' are the preferred drinking spots, all accessed via rickety cars that seem to defy the laws of safety.
'Borges And Me', a film directed by Marc Turtletaub, delves into this world, offering a hallucinatory road trip through the literary landscape of the '70s. The story follows American writer Jay Parini, played by Fionn Whitehead, as he embarks on a journey of self-discovery and mentorship. Parini, burdened by the weight of his brother's decision to join the Vietnam War, seeks guidance from various mentors, including the enigmatic academic Alistair Reid (Alan Cumming) and the legendary Argentinian poet Jorge Luis Borges (Luis Gnecco).
One of the film's intriguing aspects is the dynamic between Parini and Borges. Despite Borges' blindness since 1955, he agrees to join Parini on a road trip to the Highlands, becoming his eyes and guide. This unlikely duo forms an odd yet endearing partnership, with Borges' childlike enthusiasm and philosophical epigrams providing a unique perspective on the journey.
However, the film takes an unexpected turn when Parini's plans are derailed, and he finds himself in charge of the ailing Borges. The story takes on a surreal quality, with Borges' enigmatic presence and his penchant for tasting books (yes, you read that right!) adding a layer of intrigue.
As the road trip progresses, Parini encounters another poet, George Mackay Brown (Peter Mullan), who represents the polar opposite of Borges. Brown's dry and enigmatic nature highlights the film's exploration of artistic romanticism and the complexities of mentorship.
The film's climax occurs at the Battle of Culloden site, where Parini and Borges connect with the ghosts of the past. This scene, in my opinion, is a powerful moment that showcases the film's metafictional genius. It's a rare instance where the narrative bends towards Borges' literary influence, offering a glimpse into the film's true potential.
While 'Borges And Me' is undoubtedly smart, literary, and playful, I believe it could have benefited from a deeper exploration of Borges' metafictional genius. The film's strength lies in its ability to create a hallucinatory journey, but it sometimes feels like it's holding back, leaving the audience wanting more.
In conclusion, 'Borges And Me' is a thought-provoking film that offers a unique perspective on mentorship, literary ambition, and the power of imagination. It's a must-watch for those who appreciate a good road trip, a touch of surrealism, and a healthy dose of literary genius.
